Call analysis starts with criteria, not with listening
If a manager listens to a call without a list of criteria, the score depends on their mood and on whether they liked the rep's voice. A month later those scores cannot be compared across people or over time.
So first you break the sales script into stages and write down what counts as done for each one. Not "good discovery", but "asked at least two open questions about the client's problem and played it back in their own words". The more specific the wording, the fewer arguments in the review. How a dropped conversation gets tied to a specific stage is covered in our news piece on where sales teams lose clients inside the call.
Six blocks of criteria cover a typical sales call
The set below works for most phone sales, B2B and B2C. Trim it or extend it for your process, for example with a separate criterion for follow-up calls.
| Block | What we check | Red flag |
|---|---|---|
| Opening | Introduced themselves, named the company and the reason for the call, checked it is a good time | The client asks who is calling |
| Discovery | Open questions, the client's problem, timing, who makes the decision | Jumps to the pitch within a minute |
| Pitch | Talks about value for the client's problem, not the product in general | A monologue with no questions |
| Objections | Finds out what is behind the objection and answers the real concern | An argument, or an instant discount |
| Next step | A specific agreement: date, action, channel | "I'll call you back" with no date |
| Delivery | Pace, interruptions, the rep's share of talk time | The rep does nearly all the talking |
MakeBiz Technologies baseline criteria, November 2026. The final list is agreed against your script.
The blocks do not carry equal weight. A missed greeting rarely costs a deal, while a call with no next step almost always ends in silence. So criteria get weights: discovery and the next step score more, delivery scores less. Agree the weights with the head of sales before the first report, or the numbers will be disputed.
Read call scores by rep and by stage
An overall team average tells you very little. Two views are useful:
- by stage across the team. If almost everyone fails the next step, the problem is the script or the training, not individual people
- by rep on a single stage. If one rep keeps losing points on objections, that is the topic of their one-to-one
A third useful view is client questions and objections across all calls. Repeated questions show what to add to the script and the website, and repeated objections point to where the offer itself needs work. Much of this never makes it into the CRM, as we wrote in our news piece on what you hear on a call but never see in the deal.
